
The Lake Powell reservoir flooded miles of the Glen Canyon. (source: http://www.airphotona.com/)
The Glen Canyon Dam (completed in 1963) is known for many things – being 710 feet tall, generating approximately 4.5 billion kilowatt-hours annually, being the reason Lake Powell exists, being a particular “sinful ugly” in the eyes of Ed Abbey, “America’s most regretted environmental mistake” according to Sierra Club former executive director David Brower, fundamentally altering the flow of the Colorado River, a target for dam removal, and a gem of American renewable and independent energy.

The Glen Canyon before it was flooded (1961). (source: http://grandcanyonhistory.clas.asu.edu/, credit US Bureau of Reclamation)

A picture taken inside the Glen Caynon prior to the flooding (source: http://www.glencanyon.org/)
The River Restoration Movement’s “symbolic heart” is the Glen Canyon Dam restoration effort to remove the dam. They see this restoration effort representing “our society’s realization of the value of free-flowing rivers and complex ecosystems that depend upon them.” This is buttressed in their eyes by the argument that the Glen Canyon Dam is “the most destructive and least useful dam in the world.” Citing that over 460 dams have been removed in last 40 years, that dams pose water security threats and cause systemic harmful ecological changes (read more this here), and highlighting President Carter’s “Hit List” that cut 19 Army Corps of Engineers most environmental, economic, and safety problematic dams in 1977, the River Restoration Movement presents itself as applying rational environmental, social, political, and economic thinking when reaching their conclusion that dams should be decommissioned. Add to that their aesthetic assertion that the Glen Canyon was more beautiful prior to the dam, and they believe they are justified to remove the Glen Canyon Dam from every angle.

The basics of a hydroelectric generating dam (source: http://ga.water.usgs.gov/)
Using a dam to generate electricity from running water is relatively easy to understand. The US Bureau of Reclamation’s “Managing Water in the West: Hydroelectricity” begins by explaining the virtues; it doesn’t contribute to air pollution, the fuel (the falling water) is not consumed, is currently the most efficient form of renewable energy at 90%, the installations are time resilient, and dams are able to respond quickly to demand. The power generation itself is fairly simple: water from the reservoir passes through turbines as it falls through, which turns the turbines and generates electric energy. In short, it turns the kinetic energy of the falling water into electric energy for people to use.

A breakdown of total US energy supplies and a closer look at renewable energy. (source: http://www.iea.org)
Hydroelectric power was the source of more than 40% the US’s total energy use in the early 1920s. It was—and still is—geographically limited, requiring large rivers with a drop in elevation but the American West at the time was getting 75% of its energy from hydroelectric power. But with the development that followed, the percentage of the US’s energy dependence on hydroelectric has slowly declined to 7%, 7.6%, or 10% depending on the source. That said, hydroelectric power is still one of the top renewable energy sources in the US at 42% and can not only supply an entire state’s yearly energy usage (e.g. Idaho in 1995) but entire countries (e.g. Albania, DR of Congo, Mozambique, Nepal, Paraguay, Tajikistan, and Zambia).
According to the Colorado River Storage Project, the Glen Canyon Dam’s annual hydroelectric power generation of 4.5 billion kilowatt-hours is equal to burning 2.5 million tons of coal or 11 million barrels of oil each year. Scaling that up to the entire American West, the United States Bureau of Reclamation states that the average annual hydroelectric power generated is 42 billion kilowatt-hours, which is equal to 72 million barrels of oil.
Dams were built in the Southwest for agricultural, residential, and industrial water security during the late 1800s and into modern times. But during the height of the dam construction era of the early to mid 1900s, the additional benefit of using dams to generate hydroelectric power began to drive the construction of increasingly larger dams. Perhaps because the idea of dams already existed and could just be modified for generating hydroelectric power, or because once a hydroelectric power generating dam was done successfully it became the status quo, but the conversation surrounding Glen Canyon (and other major dams) seems to assume that dams are the only form of hydroelectric technology that exist. But as I mentioned in a previous blog, this is hardly the case. The result is that the debate surrounding the Glen Canyon Dam has divided the environmental perspective on dams into renewable energy versus ecosystem restoration while the latter maintains opposition to those responsible for maintaining and improving our nation’s water supply infrastructure.




























