Hydroelectric Fixation on Dams

flooding Glen Canyon

The Lake Powell reservoir flooded miles of the Glen Canyon. (source: http://www.airphotona.com/)

The Glen Canyon Dam (completed in 1963) is known for many things – being 710 feet tall, generating approximately 4.5 billion kilowatt-hours annually, being the reason Lake Powell exists, being a particular “sinful ugly” in the eyes of Ed Abbey, “America’s most regretted environmental mistake” according to Sierra Club former executive director David Brower, fundamentally altering the flow of the Colorado River, a target for dam removal, and a gem of American renewable and independent energy.

The Glen Canyon before it was flooded (1961). (source: http://grandcanyonhistory.clas.asu.edu/, credit US Bureau of Reclamation)

The Glen Canyon before it was flooded (1961). (source: http://grandcanyonhistory.clas.asu.edu/, credit US Bureau of Reclamation)

before the dam

A picture taken inside the Glen Caynon prior to the flooding (source: http://www.glencanyon.org/)

The River Restoration Movement’s “symbolic heart” is the Glen Canyon Dam restoration effort to remove the dam. They see this restoration effort representing “our society’s realization of the value of free-flowing rivers and complex ecosystems that depend upon them.” This is buttressed in their eyes by the argument that the Glen Canyon Dam is “the most destructive and least useful dam in the world.” Citing that over 460 dams have been removed in last 40 years, that dams pose water security threats and cause systemic harmful ecological changes (read more this here), and highlighting President Carter’s “Hit List” that cut 19 Army Corps of Engineers most environmental, economic, and safety problematic dams in 1977, the River Restoration Movement presents itself as applying rational environmental, social, political, and economic thinking when reaching their conclusion that dams should be decommissioned. Add to that their aesthetic assertion that the Glen Canyon was more beautiful prior to the dam, and they believe they are justified to remove the Glen Canyon Dam from every angle.

The basics of a hydroelectric generating dam (source: http://ga.water.usgs.gov/)

The basics of a hydroelectric generating dam (source: http://ga.water.usgs.gov/)

Using a dam to generate electricity from running water is relatively easy to understand. The US Bureau of Reclamation’s “Managing Water in the West: Hydroelectricity” begins by explaining the virtues; it doesn’t contribute to air pollution, the fuel (the falling water) is not consumed, is currently the most efficient form of renewable energy at 90%, the installations are time resilient, and dams are able to respond quickly to demand. The power generation itself is fairly simple: water from the reservoir passes through turbines as it falls through, which turns the turbines and generates electric energy. In short, it turns the kinetic energy of the falling water into electric energy for people to use.

42

A breakdown of total US energy supplies and a closer look at renewable energy. (source: http://www.iea.org)

Hydroelectric power was the source of more than 40% the US’s total energy use in the early 1920s. It was—and still is—geographically limited, requiring large rivers with a drop in elevation but the American West at the time was getting 75% of its energy from hydroelectric power. But with the development that followed, the percentage of the US’s energy dependence on hydroelectric has slowly declined to 7%, 7.6%, or 10% depending on the source. That said, hydroelectric power is still one of the top renewable energy sources in the US at 42% and can not only supply an entire state’s yearly energy usage (e.g. Idaho in 1995) but entire countries (e.g. Albania, DR of Congo, Mozambique, Nepal, Paraguay, Tajikistan, and Zambia).

According to the Colorado River Storage Project, the Glen Canyon Dam’s annual hydroelectric power generation of 4.5 billion kilowatt-hours is equal to burning 2.5 million tons of coal or 11 million barrels of oil each year. Scaling that up to the entire American West, the United States Bureau of Reclamation states that the average annual hydroelectric power generated is 42 billion kilowatt-hours, which is equal to 72 million barrels of oil.

Dams were built in the Southwest for agricultural, residential, and industrial water security during the late 1800s and into modern times. But during the height of the dam construction era of the early to mid 1900s, the additional benefit of using dams to generate hydroelectric power began to drive the construction of increasingly larger dams. Perhaps because the idea of dams already existed and could just be modified for generating hydroelectric power, or because once a hydroelectric power generating dam was done successfully it became the status quo, but the conversation surrounding Glen Canyon (and other major dams) seems to assume that dams are the only form of hydroelectric technology that exist. But as I mentioned in a previous blog, this is hardly the case. The result is that the debate surrounding the Glen Canyon Dam has divided the environmental perspective on dams into renewable energy versus ecosystem restoration while the latter maintains opposition to those responsible for maintaining and improving our nation’s water supply infrastructure.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The State of the Southwestern States’ Dams

It may come as no surprise that some of the dams in the American Southwest are hazardous. But the term has a particular meaning in the The National Inventory of Dams (NID), which is maintained by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). For NID, the dam’s “hazard potential” is classified on the basis of the anticipated consequences of failure, not the actual or current condition of the dam. With information found in their public database, this entry compares the Southwestern states’ hazardous dams.

The NID categories and definitions are:

  • high hazard potential – anticipated loss of life in the case of failure
  • significant hazard potential – anticipated damage to buildings and important infrastructure
  • low hazard potential – anticipated loss of the dam or damage to the floodplain, but no expected loss of life
CO

A map of all 1822 dams in Colorado and a graph of those dams’ hazard category. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:CO)

Let’s go through the states in a clockwise fashion with the Four Corners as the center. The construction pattern for Colorado is typical for the Southwest. There are early signs of dam building, a spike due to Reclamation Act of 1902 (an act passed to help bring agriculture to the arid West in large part through the construction of dams for irrigation purposes), a steady decline due to the WWI and WWII efforts, a significant increase following the wars, and then a rapid decline over the past half century. With this in mind, 48% of Colorado’s dams are for irrigation and a curious 13 are for “unknown” purposes.

Screen shot 2012-12-03 at 6.42.09 PM

Colorado dams by completed construction date. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:CO)

Colorado has 1,822 dams, making it the Southwestern state with the most dams, and 759 of them are highly or significantly hazardous. If 41% seems high, try to keep in mind that this is the lowest percentage in the Southwest.

AZ

A map showing Arizona’s 346 dams and their hazard levels. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:AZ)

NM

A map showing New Mexico’s 519 dams and their hazard levels. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:NM)

New Mexico with 519 dams in total and Arizona with a mere 346 – the lowest in the Southwest – have similar profiles. In New Mexico, 60% of dams are highly or significantly hazardous, and in Arizona, 57% are. These two states also differ from the rest of the Southwest by their ownership; New Mexico is the only state with more local government owned dams (39%) than privately owned dams (27%), and Arizona is the only other state even close with 24% of its dams owned by the local government and 40% of its dams privately owned. They are also different from the rest of the Southwest by their primary water usage: New Mexico is the only Southwestern state where “flood control” is the largest primary use, whereas Arizona has an equal amount of dams with “flood control” and “irrigation” as their primary use.

CA

A map of California’s 1468 dams and a graph showing their hazard levels. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:CA)

California has the second highest amount of dams in the Southwestern states with 1,468. It also has the second highest percentage of hazardous dams in the Southwest at 69%. This is of particular importance given the significant irrigation for agriculture role Californian dams play, which is the primary use at 46%. This means that despite the NID not providing more contextualized data indicating the portions of hazardous dams in their other figures, there is no way to slice the numbers and not have a significant amount of the agricultural sector supplied by hazardous dams in California.

Screen shot 2012-12-03 at 6.51.38 PM

The distribution of Californian dams’ primary ownership. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:CA)

The ownership profile of California’s dams are unique in the
Southwestern states for having the most normal distribution (i.e. a bell shape is a normal distribution, not an even distribution) among federal, local government, private, public utility company, and state. Arguably this is reflection of the role public utilities play in ownership, as they aren’t even included in Nevada’s profile and they own an extremely small portion in Colorado (5%), New Mexico (3.7%), Arizona (3.8%), and Utah (3.3%). Compared to these numbers, California’s 21% seems enormous.

UT

A map of Utah’s 818 dams and a graph showing their hazard category quantities. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:UT)

NV

A map of Nevada’s 516 dams and a graph showing their hazard category quantities. (source: http://geo.usace.army.mil/pgis/f?p=397:3:0::NO::P3_STATES:NV)

Bringing the clock back to 12 brings us to the last two states of the American Southwest: Nevada and Utah. Where Nevada is fairly average for its hazardous dam percentage at 52%, Utah has the highest percentage at 73%! Its primary use, primary owner, and construction profiles are typical for the Southwest, but perhaps the significant contribution to this high hazardous dam percentage can be found in the state’s dam height profile: 65% of its dams are less than 25 feet! Perhaps this is also the reason why Utah has one of the highest ratios of Emergency Action Plans (EAP) for its high hazard potential (100%) and significant hazard potential (68%) dams. It is worth noting that there are number discrepancies here – NID reports Utah has having 348 dams with a significant hazard potential, but then reports a total of 93 in another figure breaking down which of those dams have EAPs. 

So where does all of this leave us? The Water Resource Development Act of 1996 established the National Dam Safety Program (NDSP), which is a national dam safety program administered by the Federal Emergency Management Agency designed to provide incentive grants to states and training to encourage research. Their job is to change the damnation of the nation’s dams. While there have been successes and improvements as a result of the NDSP, the safety and condition of the nation’s dams have not improved overall. 50% of the nation’s dams are of a high hazard, and 30% of those dams have not been inspected in over 5 years. Why? Many state dam safety programs do not have sufficient resources, funding, or staff to conduct dam safety inspections, to take appropriate enforcement actions, or to ensure proper construction by reviewing plans and performing construction inspections. Death by numbers is perhaps on the horizon.

Posted in Uncategorized | 3 Comments

Breaking a 6 Million Year Old Tradition

This map shows the historic route of the Colorado River reaching the Sea of Cortez. (source: http://www.theworld.org/)

This map shows the historic route of the Colorado River reaching the Sea of Cortez. (source: http://www.theworld.org/)

For 6 million years, the water in the Colorado River ended its flowing journey of 1,450 miles by meeting the Sea of Cortez in the Gulf of Mexico. But in 1983 this did not happen. What little water now enters into Mexico dries up in the sand about 75 miles short of the sea. Since this first happened, the Colorado River has met the Sea of Cortez only a handful of times, most recently in 1998, and this is only during a particularly wet year. This has raised concerns for how dams change the land and aquatic based ecology in addition to societal, specifically agricultural, concerns.

Screen shot 2012-12-02 at 5.52.18 PM

The fishing in the Colorado Delta of Mexico used to be exceptionally good. (source: http://ncep.amnh.org/)

What was lost? The Delta del Rio Colorado (the Colorado River Delta) was a historic desert estuary with over 2.5 million acres of wetlands. The wetlands were a rare mosaic of freshwater, riparian, brackish, and tidal wetlands. Estimates place 400 species of plants and wildlife as having depended on this nutrient rich water and silt fed ecosystem, in addition to 20,000 Cocopah Indians. Fishing, hunting, and farming were not only possible in the Colorado Delta, but extremely fruitful endeavors as seen in the size of the harvested fish. Patrick Graham of The Nature Conservancy in Arizona thinks that it would count as the eighth wonder of the world, were it around today.

Screen shot 2012-12-02 at 5.24.29 PM

The dam construction of the 30s on significantly changed the flow measured at Yuma, Arizona. (source: http://ncep.amnh.org/)

How did this happen and why? Southwestern cities in the early to mid 1900s were growing and this placed a high demand on water. 1936 brought the completion of the Hoover Dam (creating Lake Mead), which is seen as the first significant dam built on the Colorado River. River flow measured at Yuma, Arizona show just how dramatic of a change the Hoover Dam had on in-stream flow. Following this came the Imperial Dam in 1938, the Davis Dam in 1953, the Glen Canyon Dam in 1959 (creating Lake Powell), and the Parker Dam in 1971, just to name a few of the major dams on the Colorado River. (For a better overview of dams in the Southwest, see this.) Dams also change the role of water in riparian ecosystems: the seasonal flooding of the plains deposit essential nutrients and the surge of water activate the germination of submerged seeds. In effect, the environmental conditions that vegetation in these areas evolved to meet changed in a matter of years and compromised habitat.

Screen shot 2012-12-02 at 5.36.19 PM

This map shows how the changing salinity concentrations of the Colorado River. (source: http://ncep.amnh.org/)

How is the water different? One major issue that was overlooked for many years is the temperature of the water flowing out of the dams. Because dams release water from the bottom of the reservoir, and water at the bottom of these man made lakes are colder than water at the top, the release water can be 15 degrees colder in the 20 miles of tailwaters downstream. And as described above, the sediment in the water is no longer able to spread across the floodplains with seasonal floods. Instead, it stays behind the dam in the reservoir, making the water cloudier. Concurrent with this is an increase in salinity concentrations due to how the water basin carries salt dissolved in water back to the river, but the river has less water in it because of the diversions. The result is a saltier, cloudier, and colder reservoir and river, which again, marks a stark shift in environmental conditions that many native fish are unable to cope with.  

These two images illustrate a comparison of historic and current conditions in the Colorado Delta. (source: http://ncep.amnh.org/)

These two images illustrate a comparison of historic and current conditions in the Colorado Delta. (source: http://ncep.amnh.org/)

What has happened to Mexico? During the 20th century, river flows into the Delta have been reduced nearly 75%, from an annual average of 16.7 million acre-feet between 1896 to 1921, to an annual average of 4.2 million acre-feet between 1984 and 1999. And along with this lowered quantity of water is the lowered quality: the water carries less silt and nutrients, and more salt and pollutants. The result today is the Delta is now 5% of its former size and the ecological composition is different due to locally evolved species being unable to adapt to the changes in the environmental conditions.

A map of the Reserve (source: http://www.dondepescar.com/)

A map of the Reserve (source: http://www.dondepescar.com/)

Now what? In 1993, Mexico declared 2.3 million acres of water and land in the delta as the Reserva de la Biosfera del Alto Golfo de California y Delta del Rio Colorado (Biosphere Reserve for the Gulf of California and Colorado River Delta) and established a core area of 400,000 acres strictly for research, and low impact revenue generation such as shellfish harvesting and ecotourism. In an attempt to continue these restoration efforts, Mexico and the U.S. signed a new agreement to help feed water into these wetlands in a hope to perhaps partially restore it for ecological and agricultural purposes on November 21, 2012.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Cheesman Dam

Denver, CO was the second most populated city in the West of 1890s. It grew from 5,000 to more than 100,000 in step with the surge of railroad development from 1870 to 1890. At the time, Denver residents simply drew their water from the South Platte River, but the flow was neither steady enough nor large enough to meet the growing demand. The rate of population growth and the shear population numbers meant that Denver needed a dependable water supply, which meant that a reservoir was needed. It was time for Colorado to build its first dam.

cheesman-walter-1

Walter Scott Cheeseman (source: http://cheesmanpark.net/)

Businessmen and pioneers Walter Scott Cheesman and David Moffat were involved in consolidating small water companies into Denver Union Water Company in the 1890s and running the company in its early years. Cheesman in particular was adamant about keeping Denver’s water supply “a Denver enterprise” without the investment and control of outsiders. This vision or mentality of Denver’s water carries on today, as the Cheesman Dam allowed for a large supply to be delivered quickly through an independently financed infrastructure. Thus, if the supply exists and there aren’t any outside ties to restrain the use, the question of water use shifts from can Denver get enough water to how will Denver continue to receive enough water.

construction

The Cheesman Dam under construction, approximately 1904 (source: http://history.denverlibrary.org/)

But the construction story itself is interesting. Chief Engineer C.P. Allen originally found the site for the dam on Goose Creek and started construction in 1898 using a new “gravity arch” design to redirect the reservoir’s stress away from the dam itself and onto the surrounding natural rock. But with the Spring of 1900 came a quick and strong flood that washed away the entire project’s progress. Later that same year, Cheesman and his crew selected another site along the South Platte River and began building a better dam. The gravity arch design was kept and the spillway was raised to 221 feet, which made it the world’s tallest dam upon completion. Italian masons were brought on board to quarry and cut the local granite. The finely cut stones, each four to five tons, literally became the face of the Cheesman Dam as they were the facing stones of the dam. Construction finished 1905 and C.P. Allen was reportedly so pleased with the masonry’s aesthetic and functional success that he gave a $50 suit to the head mason.

early

The Cheesman Dam 5 years after completion. (source: http://www.denverwater.org )

But the completion of the dam was not entirely smooth. The Denver Union Company had created a subsidiary company to fund and orchestrate the project, and legend has it that as the money began to run low towards the end of the project, Cheesman himself personally contributed substantially money to ensure the completion.

today

The Cheesman Dam in recent years. It is now well known for it’s striking aesthetics as the rocks used in the dam help it blend into the landscape. (source: http://www.flyfishingaddicts.com/)

Once the dam became operational, it marked the first “online storage” of water for Denver. It is remarkable that it’s original capacity of 89,000 acre-feet maintained over the last century. The Douglas County History organization created a video of this history and provides additionally insight into the recreational and aesthetic benefits of the dam. Indeed, in 1973 the American Society of Civil Engineers designated Cheesman Dam a National Historic Landmark for how well it blended into is surroundings and its integrity. It is seen as a “jewel” among the Southwestern dams and perhaps this makes it count as an exceptional piece of land art.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Dams as Land Art

We as a global, national, and regional society have dramatically changed our relationship with the earth in the recent decades. And how we artistically express ourselves reflects these undercurrents of awareness and critique. Beginning in the land art movement, moving into the American Southwest, and then focusing on how dams in the American Southwest are becoming recognized as land art in recent years illustrates how not only society is changing in general, but more specifically how the role of art mediating our relationship with existence is growing to include natural resources like water and societal necessitates like sustainable energy.

spiral_jetty_big

Smithson’s installation of the Spiral Jetty in the Great Salt Lake of Utah is a composition of mud and salt that causes changes in the water inside the spiral.
(source: http://www.robertsmithson.com/)

Land art made its globally recognized debut with the 1968 “Earthworks” exhibition in New York City’s Virginia Dwan Gallery and has grown into a movement. The works were radical in the sense that works like Robert Smithson’s Spiral Jetty were completely rejecting traditional sculpture, modern art theory, and consequentially, the role of materials in creating art. The movement was born out of the protesting mentality that characterized the post-Progressive era and quickly grew in purpose and form.

Double Negative

Heizer’s piece Double Negative is the documentation of two 50 foot deep, 30 foot wide, 1,500 foot long trenches that were dynamited intentionally by Heizer in a way that is suggestive of mining.
(source: http://doublenegative.tarasen.net/)

Land art established that rock and grass, soil and sand, rivers and oceans, sunlight and moonlight, branches and trees, and other found natural objects were legitimate inspirational and constructive tools for art. Additionally, the commentary resulting from their juxtaposition with industrial materials and man-made landscape alternations like Michael Heizer’s Double Negative carried another message: we can no longer deny that our extraction of natural resources changes the land.

The American West, and particularly the American Southwest, offered the expansive and remote deserts that formed the foundation of the early and anti-establishment land art. But as the critiquing power of this artistic expression grew and the forms taken diversified, land art became a legitimate foundation for architecture colleges, art centers based out of universities, and exhibits. For example, the Land Arts of the American West at Texas Tech (but started in the University of New Meixco in 2000) offers a “transdisciplinary field program investigating the intersection of geomorphology and human construction” where students spend two months exploring and blogging about their 6,000 miles trip across Arizona, Meixco, New Mexico, Nevada, Utah, and Texas for land art constructions and centers. They visit landscapes that are shaped by natural and human forces, and they interpret this widely to include “geology and weather to cigarette butts and hydroelectric dams” The Hoover Dam, Coolidge Dam, and the artificially created reservoir Lake Mead are in their list of previously visited sites. Perhaps more broadly, the Center for Art + Environment at the Nevada Museum of Art specifically endeavors to create art that expresses “ interaction between people and their natural, built, and virtual environments,” document it, and increase public knowledge of this creative critique.

Some see the Hoover Dam currently as land art. (source: http://www.nowpublic.com/culture/cables-hung-bridge-over-hoover-dam-photo-02)

Some see the Hoover Dam currently as land art. (source: http://www.nowpublic.com/culture/cables-hung-bridge-over-hoover-dam-photo-02)

Some would prefer to reimagine it in an effort to turn the concept of a Hoover Dam into land art. (source: http://vi.sualize.us/hoover_reimagined_yheu-shen_chua_land_art_dam_sculpture_picture_nbyJ.html)

Some would prefer to reimagine it in an effort to turn the concept of a Hoover Dam into land art. (source: http://vi.sualize.us/hoover_reimagined_yheu-shen_chua_land_art_dam_sculpture_picture_nbyJ.html)

An explanation of how vortex hydroelectric energy works. It is perhaps one of the least environmentally impact hydroelectric energy technologies. (source: http://www.sherwoodinstitute.org/blog/)

An explanation of how vortex hydroelectric energy works. It is perhaps one of the least environmentally impact hydroelectric energy technologies.
(source: http://www.sherwoodinstitute.org/blog/)

The Land Art Generator Initiative (LAGI) moves from critique to construction. It’s main goal is to “design and construct public art installations that have the added benefit of large scale clean energy generation,” and in order to this, hydroelectric power plays a significant role in LAGI’s initiative because it is currently the most established alterative energy source at 20% globally. They have developed Run of the River (Damless Hydro), Micro and Pico Hydro (for smaller rivers), Vortex Power (installed on the water body floor), and many other hydroelectric power designs without the use of dams. By breaking the assumption that hydroelectric power must come from dams, and supplying alternatives that generate more diverse, less environmentally impactful, and perhaps even more aseptically pleasing to even the untrained eye, LAGI is codifying the role of land in sustainable energy.

If interested in LAGI, they reach out through competitions structured around 1) understanding art outside of the gallery, 2) understanding the science of energy, 3) understanding sustainable technologies, 4) constructing a conceptual framework for the functional land art installation, 5) designing the land art, and ultimately 6) submitting the design. Their portfolios can be viewed here

Posted in Uncategorized | 4 Comments

Dam(n) the Southwestern United States!

Pun aside, dam construction made the Southwest U.S.’s population and agriculture boom in the 20th century while simultaneously making the future of those cities and crops more vulnerable to water scarcity in the 21st century and beyond.

Figure 1 – Annual Rainfall in the Southwest (http://www.learnnc.org/lp/editions/mapping/6414)

Different sources cut the south-west out of United States differently. Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, Utah, and Nevada are counted across the board, but sometimes California and even Texas are included. But lets not allow this variation to distract us from the main point: the Southwestern U.S. is an arid region (see Figure 1).

John Wesley Powell traveled into the West to conduct a U.S. Geological Survey in the late 1800s. Struck by the stark difference in aridity—the moist east and dry west—he wrote in an 1879 report that the 100th Meridian is a useful dividing line, which is a term still in use today. This line is not arbitrary; rather, it actually explains why Powell saw the West as “worthless lands”: the 100th Meridian approximates where the yearly rainfall amount necessary for non-irrigation agriculture (20 inches).

Figure 2 – Colorado River Basin dams (http://www.usbr.gov/lc/phoenix/AZ100/1960/photogallery.html)

What changed? What changed is that people have modified the watersheds through an extensive network of dams, diversions, canals, reservoirs, and pipelines to the point that watershed modification in the West in general is “nearly a ubiquitous condition”. But the pivotal structure is the dam. There are the five major watersheds in the Southwestern U.S.: the Upper and Lower Colorado Basin watershed, the Great Basin watershed, the Rio Grande watershed, and the California watershed. Focusing on the total Colorado watershed, more than 20 dams are on the Colorado River and its tributaries (see Figure 2). And according to this National Geographic “Colorado River Map Zoomifier” (not my term) there are 30 dams; 27 run or store water (1 of which is in Wyoming and another is on the Arizona-Mexico border) and 3 are diversion dams.

The Colorado River was thought to have an annual flow of 17.5 million acre feet (maf) of water. This figure was the corner stone used in the 1922 Colorado River Compact and then reinforced in the Treaty of February 3, 1944 to establish U.S. and Mexico water allocations and construction rights for the the Rio Grande. Mexico was granted 1.5 maf but the average annual flow is 14.7 maf—this difference of 2.8 maf means the Colorado River no longer flows into Mexico because all of the upstream dams, diversions, and canals move and use it up before it reaches Mexico. These annual flow numbers are getting worse with increased drought and are expected to decrease more with climate change.

Figure 3 – Water Withdrawal per State (http://ga.water.usgs.gov/edu/wateruse-total.html)

From that surface water flow, 11.46 maf is withdrawn and used for agriculture, and 3.23 maf is withdrawn and used for municipal and industrial uses. This extraction of water explains how the Southwest can have a low annual rainfall while still having a higher rate of domestic and agricultural use than the eastern states (see Figure 3).

But dams serve purposes beyond simply shunting water for irrigation purposes. They store the water for generating hydroelectric power and promote socially valued recreational activities. They also store the water for drier times and reduce disvalued events like floods. Returning to our focus, the hydroelectric power of the Colorado dams totals 12 billion kilowatt-hours per year.

Figure 4 – Domestic Water Use in Gallons per Day per Person and Projected Percent Population Change by 2030 (Source: Water data from USGS, Estimated Use of Water in the United States in 2000, County-level data for 2000; population data from U.S. Census Bureau, State Interim Population Projections: 2004–2030)

But the drawback of this storage system means water evaporates, thus reducing the amount of water flow. To illustrate, let’s take the two largest water storage dams on the Colorado River: the Glen Canyon Dam, which creates Lake Powell, and the Hoover Dam, which creates Lake Mead. Together, these two dams provide about 80% of the Colorado Basin water-storage capacity. But also, together these two lakes evaporate 1.07 maf per year. Agriculture also removes water from the flow by releasing water vapor through the process of evapotranspiration. This is known as “consumptive” or “destructive” use of water, as compared to “nonconsumptively” or “nondestructively” using water and returning it to the river without reducing the volume between the take and replacement.

Spring precipitation change for 2080-2099 compared to 1961-1979 under two emissions scenarios. High confidence in the projected changes is indicated by hatched areas. Source: USGCRP (2009)

With all of these past changes to the Southwestern U.S.’s water systems, dams have made the area wet enough for agriculture. But, we increasingly understand that this means our water systems build in habits of use, particularly overpumping, place the growing cities of Southwest in uncertain water futures. Add to that the near future climate change predictions coupled with the fact that the Southwest still leads the nation in population growth, and you begin to grasp just how big of an issue water scarcity will inevitably become (see Figures 4 and 5).

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

testing… damn the literature!

“All dams are ugly, but the Glen Canyon Dam is sinful ugly.”

– Ed Abbey

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 1 Comment